|
|
SYMPOSIUM:
WEAPONS CHOICES
SECTION: Tamponade
Moderators: Klaus Lucke, Athanasios Nikolakopoulos
Monday, September 15th, 2003 ; 8:30 - 10:30
EXPERIENCE
WITH F6H8 AS HEAVY TAMPONADE IN REPAIRING
COMPLICATED INFERIOR RD AND PVR
Sven Crafoord
Orebro, Sweden
Purpose: To report
our clinical experience using a hydrofluorocarbon liquid (HFCL) i.e. (F6H8)
as a 3-4 weeks tamponade in complicated retinal detachment and PVR, in
comparison with silicone oil.
Methods: 15 patients, 8 women 7 men with a mean age 54 years, were included
in the F6H8 tamponade-group. Two patients had giant breaks, one penetrating
eye injury, seven PVR and five retinal redetachments in the two lower
quadrants. Of 15 patients operated with silicone oil or expanding gas,
9 were women 6 men, mean age 55 years. 8 cases had PVR and 7 had various
complicated retinal detachments.
Results:
| Eye
status at last visit |
F6H8
(n =15)
|
Silicone
oil tamponade
(n =15)
|
| Mean
follow-up (months) |
13,4
|
8,9
|
| Attached
retina |
12
|
12
|
| Temp
detached |
1
|
0
|
| Inferiorly
detached |
0
|
2
|
| Totally
detached |
2
|
1
|
| BCVA
improved |
1
|
9
|
| BCVA
unchanged |
8
|
6
|
| BCVA
deteriorated |
6
|
0
|
| Silicone
oil in situ |
6
|
2
|
| Mean
nr of reoperations |
2
|
1
|
Complications: Temporary
elevated IOP were seen in two patients, droplets of F6H8 entering the
anterior chamber in seven patients, progression of cataract in one patient.
No patients appeared with subretinal F6H8.
Conclusions: Using hydrofluorocarbon liquid (HFCL) like F6H8 as a tenuous
3-week tamponade seems to increase the chance of reattaching the retina
in the two lower quadrants. Compared to "standard" tamponade
procedures using silicone oil the results are similar concerning anatomic
reattachment. However the BCVA measured at last visit are much worse in
the F6H8 group. One explanation could be that these patients had a more
complex pathology reflected in higher amount of reoperations but we can
not rule out a certain toxic effect of F6H8, which would negatively influence
the final BCVA results.
Take-home message: F6H8 offers a new approach to reattach severely PVR
folded or wrinkled retinas. Whether F6H8 induce a toxic effect to the
retina perhaps due to its density or chemical properties is indicated
but not verified.
|